Two of the most popular IT service delivery models are managed IT services and in-house IT teams. These two approaches offer distinct advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between them can significantly impact an organisation’s efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and ability to adapt to technological challenges. As the IT landscape continues to evolve, it’s vital for businesses to make informed decisions about their IT infrastructure and support systems. In this article, we delve into an assessment of the pros and cons associated with both managed IT services and maintaining an in-house IT team. By exploring the advantages and disadvantages you can better determine the most suitable IT solution to meet your needs. 

Managed IT services or in-house IT

The decision to use Managed IT Services should be based on your organisation’s size, your specific business needs, your budget, and your priorities. Some businesses may benefit from a combination of both, using in-house IT for core functions and outsourcing specific tasks or expertise when needed. There are definite advantages to both managed IT services and in-house IT. It’s essential to carefully evaluate the potential disadvantages of each and ensure that any chosen providers align with your company’s goals and expectations. 

Pros of Managed IT Services

Managed IT services operate on a subscription or pay-as-you-go model. This is often more cost-effective than hiring and maintaining an in-house IT team. It can reduce labour costs, infrastructure expenses, and the need for training. Typically there’s a team of specialists with diverse skills and knowledge which allows you to tap into a broader range of IT expertise than you might have with an in-house team. 

Managed IT services can easily scale up or down based on your business needs and growth. Scalability will allow you to adapt to changing business requirements without the hassle of hiring or dismissing staff. Managed IT often means that your IT infrastructure is monitored 24/7 and issues are proactively addressed before they become major problems. This can lead to improved system reliability and reduced downtime. By outsourcing IT management, your internal team can concentrate on core business functions, strategic initiatives, and innovation rather than getting held back by day-to-day IT issues.

Summary of pros for consideration: 

  • Cost-effectiveness,  
  • Access to a range of expertise, 
  • Scalability and flexibility, 
  • Proactive maintenance and support, 
  • Focus on core business functions. 

Cons of Managed IT Services

Managed IT service providers aren’t always physically present on-site. This can be a drawback for businesses that require immediate, in-person assistance for certain issues during business hours. If the IT provider happens to experience downtime or other issues, your business operations can also be affected. Effective communication between your business and the managed IT services provider is crucial. Miscommunication or delays in response times can lead to frustration and service disruptions. 

Entrusting an external party with access to your company’s IT infrastructure and data can also raise privacy and security concerns. It’s essential to have robust contracts and security measures in place to address these issues. Managed IT service providers handle multiple clients. This means that they may prioritise issues differently than how you would if you had an in-house team. This means you may have less control over the order in which your IT problems are addressed.

Summary of cons for consideration: 

  • Limited on-site presence,
  • Dependency on third-party providers,
  • Potential for communication challenges, 
  • Privacy and data concerns,
  • Less control over prioritisation. 

Pros of In-House IT

In-house IT teams have a deep understanding of a company’s operations, culture, and specific IT needs. This familiarity can lead to more tailored solutions. With an in-house team, you have IT professionals physically present in your organisation, attributing to faster response times and on-site support when issues arise. In-house IT professionals are often more closely integrated into the company culture and can align their work with the broader organisational goals and values. Full control over your IT infrastructure and data security means you can provide a higher level of confidence and assurance in terms of protecting sensitive information that you may be responsible for. You’ll have direct control over the IT projects and initiatives that your team focuses on, allowing you to tailor their efforts to match your business priorities.

Summary of pros for consideration: 

  • In-depth knowledge of the company,
  • Immediate response and hands-on support,
  • Alignment with company culture,
  • Data security and control, 
  • Customisation and prioritisation. 

Cons of In-House IT

Maintaining an in-house IT team may be too expensive for your organisation due to salaries, benefits, training, and infrastructure costs. Finding and retaining skilled IT professionals can be competitive and challenging. High demand for IT talent can result in higher turnover rates and increased recruitment efforts.

In-house teams can lack expertise in specialised areas of IT. This becomes a limitation when dealing with complex or niche technologies or projects. Providing 24/7 IT support with an in-house team can be cost-prohibitive and challenging due to the need for shift work and overtime. An in-house IT team might rely on a limited set of vendors or technologies, potentially missing out on the latest innovations and best practices from a broader range of IT providers.

Summary of cons for consideration: 

  • Higher costs,
  • Recruitment and retention, 
  • Limited access to specialised skills, 
  • Unable to match 24/7 support,
  • Possible lack of vendor diversity.

Choosing your IT provider 

Choosing between Managed IT Services and an In-House IT team, or a combination of both, requires careful consideration of your organisation’s IT infrastructure, capabilities, specific IT service needs and budget. An evaluation of the pros and cons of both service delivery models will guide your IT strategy and long-term success. 

Explore our Managed IT Services and see how we can help your business. Let us take care of your IT services, so you can focus on running your business.

Cyber Security for Employees


Ensure your business is protected from the front line

Get my free guide